
I've said it before: I WANT the HTC Shift. However, as more details become available, I have to ask myself if I am making the correct decision. This is especially in light of new products (and expanded range of current products) hitting the market. I have to thank Kaz911 for being in Dubai at the right time to ask the right people about the Shift. He posted full specs and a brief interview - both of which are helping my decision making.
Let's go issue by issue:
Specs:
The final specs include the Stealey at 800 MHz. This chip's performance has been shown in depth with the Samsung Q1 Ultra line. A gig of RAM, Vista Business, and an 800x480 touchscreen are par for the course. The HSDPA frequencies (850, 1900, and 2100 MHz) means that the built in mobile broadband may only work on T-Mobile in the USA or may not work at all. It'd have to be tested. It is also confirmed in Kas911's interview above that the Shift does NOT have full Windows Mobile but what appears to be an advanced BIOS that may have Windows CE components. Barring the HSDPA radio (which would require a contract and a new line of service anyway) the Shift doesn't offer me anything other UMPCs do.
Limitations on Improvement:
The HTC shift does not offer a dock, extended battery, or Synaptics pointer. Also missing are dedicated scroll up/down keys, which I have found to be essential in slate mode.
Style:
The Shift wins hands-down in the Style contest. The form factor, size, weight, design, edges, comfort, balance, and more make it the sexiest UMPC to date. How much am I willing to pay for that? It comes at a price, though. I love slates because they're single, solid units without moving parts thus are more durable and less prone to physical damage. If I choose to have moving parts, why not get a tablet that's a convertible so at least the screen is protected when closed?
Competition and Price:
The HTC Shift, as I pre-ordered it from Dynamism, is US$1,500. This is with an Intel A110 CPU and a gig of RAM.
Dynamism also carries:
- Raon Everun for $799
- OQO model 02 starting at $1299 (after $200 instant rebate)
- Samsung Q1 Ultra starting at $999
Also on the horizon are the VIA Nanobook and Asus Eee - both devices with tiny footprints and tiny prices. I'd pick the Nanobook if given the chance between the two, but am disappointed that it does not offer a regular slate mode. Since the Nanobook is a reference design, perhaps a manufacturer will modify it (remember the Vadem CLIO?) to give it a convertible slate mode.
Finally, there's the Amtek T770. It's not revolutionary compared to my eo v7110, but it is evolutionary. It offers a 1.2 GHz C7M and VX700 with Unichrome Pro2 graphics, louder speakers, better touchscreen accuracy and sensitivity and a webcam. I seriously doubt it will out-price the Samsung devices or OQO 02. Depending on how it performs with Vista (and if it can support 2GB RAM) I may end up with a T770 instead.
What happens now?
I am going to carefully consider my pre-order of the Shift. I may not end up with it after all. Without a Shift, I would probably by a Samsung Q1 Ultra (800 Mhz, 60gb HD, 1.0GB RAM, Windows XP Tablet Edition for $1279 and test it with XP,) then give it a 2 GB SO-DIMM and put my own copy of Vista Ultimate on it for comparison's sake.
Since I write to help UMPC owners and potential owners, I will take any advice on my 2nd generation UMPC.

6 comments:
To add to all my disappointments over the HTC Shift, I read that you can't upgrade the memory past 1GB (unless there are 2GB Micro-DIMM modules out there).
How about the Kohjinsha SH8? Yup, the SH8, 800mhz. Have it at 2GB ram.
I'm looking seriously at the ASUS R2Hv-A1 - a Pentium M processor with 4 cell Battery (~4hrs), and a BatteryGeeks PPS for additonal battery time.
Jenneth over at GearDiary.com has one and is blogging good stuff about it.
I've been very interested in the Shift since it's announcement, the design is straight up sexy. But with this weekend's disappointing announcements, I've starting looking other places to get my design/mobile fix. I've become obsessed with the 12.1" notebooks as of late, especially the HP TX1000 series with it's convertible screen. How would you compare this small notebook to the shift. I see it as being just as mobile as the shift and would allow more productivity, and for a cheaper price. Both of them would need a bag to carry. other items of comparison???
I did a similar round of the new HTC news over at:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=328697
Nut for the most part I think the only core issue the Shift faces which dimishes its value is the 2 hours battery life.
I fail to see how
1. HTC who has provided us with devices which can run on days on end, much to everyones surprise (Advantage) would push out a product with 2 Hours battery life.
2. Hugo spent 3 days with this thing, im pretty confident if the battery life was 2 hours we would have noticed.
3. Official specs still aren't on HTC page.
I just feel it might be too early to be cancelling pre-orders or judging this device.
As for everyones uproar about the screen, I just dont feel that to be an issue worthy of rejecting the device. Its a 7" screen, whilst 1024 would be good 800x480 is still pleasent, and where other companies have failed with upscaling, the 1024 upscale on Hugos video looked alright. On top of that, its 2" bigger than the advantage screen, the advantage works a treat in 640x480 but if it went up to 1024 im pretty sure even i'd struggle to see it.
Now, whilst its risky to market a device this late in 2007 with these specs, on the whole, HDD, processor, RAM, and its potential, it could still be a worthy investment IF the battery life issue turns out to be up to the 3hr mark. Otherwise for 2hrs battery life, I agree with the Shift website "Why comprise?"
In case you are still looking, Rob Bushway hints a possible dual active digitizer & touchscreen in the future for OQO at http://www.gottabemobile.com/OQOUpdatesTheModel02TabletPC.aspx
Still should try one to make sure screen is not too small. Sorry to hear HTC Touch turned out a hype, even if it lived up to expectations it still targets a different consumer than the OQO 02.
Post a Comment